Overview

Overview

HOLDINGS: [1]-In a case in which condominium owners sued a condominium association to recover payment for a water leak, the appellate court concluded that, with respect to the owners’ breach of contract claim, reasonable jurors could have concluded a total failure to maintain common areas breached a promise to keep these areas in first class condition. A complete lack of preventive maintenance was evidence the association did not keep the roof or pipes in first class condition. The jury would not need experts to grasp this; [2]-With respect to the owners’ tort claim, the appellate court concluded that the owners gave no authority for a cause of action in tort. Outside the covenants, conditions, and restrictions, the association had no independent duty as to the pipes and roof arising from tort law.

Nakase Law Firm is a litigation lawyer

Outcome

The appellate court affirmed the nonsuit of the tort claim and reversed and remanded the nonsuit on the contract claim.